Ithaca, New York, a vibrant college town nestled in the Finger Lakes region, boasts an impressive selection of liquor stores that cater to diverse tastes and budgets. From cozy neighborhood shops to expansive retail chains, Ithaca’s liquor scene offers something for every connoisseur. This comprehensive guide explores the best liquor stores in Ithaca, providing detailed information to help you find the perfect bottle for your next gathering or solo indulgence.

Independent Establishments for Local Charm
The Wine Cellar
- Specializes in: Fine wines, craft beers, and artisanal spirits
- Atmosphere: Intimate, cozy, and knowledgeable staff
- Price Range: Varies, but expect to find a wide range of options
- Best for: Wine enthusiasts, craft beer aficionados, and spirit lovers seeking unique selections
Collegetown Beverage Center
- Specializes in: Beer and wine, with a wide variety of domestic and international options
- Atmosphere: Friendly, knowledgeable, and a popular gathering spot for students
- Price Range: Competitive prices and frequent sales
- Best for: College students, beer enthusiasts, and those looking for value
Purity Ice Cream and Beverage
- Specializes in: Beer, wine, and liquor, with a strong focus on local breweries and wineries
- Atmosphere: Family-owned and friendly, offers a quaint and welcoming atmosphere
- Price Range: Mid-range, with competitive prices for local products
- Best for: Supporting local businesses, finding Ithaca-crafted beverages, and enjoying a sense of community
Retail Chains for Convenience and Selection
Wegmans Food Markets
- Specializes in: Groceries, including a vast selection of beer, wine, and liquor
- Atmosphere: Large, well-stocked, and conveniently located
- Price Range: Varies, but typically offers competitive prices and discounts on bulk purchases
- Best for: One-stop shopping, finding a wide variety of beverages, and taking advantage of grocery store convenience
Target
- Specializes in: General merchandise, including a decent selection of beer, wine, and liquor
- Atmosphere: Spacious, organized, and easy to navigate
- Price Range: Mid-range, with occasional discounts and sales
- Best for: Quick grocery runs, convenience, and those who prefer to shop at a familiar store
Walmart
- Specializes in: Groceries, electronics, home goods, and a limited selection of beer, wine, and liquor
- Atmosphere: Large, discount-oriented, and may not offer the same ambiance as other liquor stores
- Price Range: Budget-friendly, with competitive prices on select products
- Best for: Value shoppers, finding everyday beverages at a low cost, and convenience
Where to Find Specialized Spirits and Unique Finds
The Watershed
- Specializes in: Craft spirits, whiskey, and rare vintages
- Atmosphere: Sophisticated, elegant, and a destination for whiskey enthusiasts
- Price Range: High-end, with exceptional spirits worth the investment
- Best for: Connoisseurs, whiskey lovers, and those seeking exclusive bottles
FLX Wienery
- Specializes in: Natural wines, craft beers, and a curated selection of spirits
- Atmosphere: Vibrant, trendy, and a hub for food and beverage lovers
- Price Range: Mid-range, with a focus on supporting local and independent producers
- Best for: Natural wine enthusiasts, those seeking unique flavors, and those who appreciate a lively atmosphere
Bacchus Wine & Spirits
- Specializes in: Fine wines, rare spirits, and gourmet food items
- Atmosphere: Luxurious, knowledgeable, and a destination for discerning palates
- Price Range: High-end, offering exceptional wines and spirits of rare vintage and quality
- Best for: Wine collectors, spirit enthusiasts, and those looking for exclusive products
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming you’ll find the best selection at the largest store: While large retail chains offer convenience, they may not always have the most extensive or specialized selection.
- Neglecting to check local liquor laws: Ithaca has specific regulations regarding alcohol sales. Always verify operating hours and any restrictions before planning your visit.
- Overlooking independent establishments: Local liquor stores often carry unique and locally produced beverages that you may not find elsewhere.
- Going shopping without a budget: Set a budget before you start shopping to avoid overspending.
- Ignoring knowledgeable staff: Liquor store staff can provide valuable recommendations and help you find the perfect bottle.
Frequently Asked Questions
- What are the legal drinking and purchasing ages in Ithaca, NY? 21 years old
- Are there any restrictions on bringing alcohol into New York State? Yes, there are limitations on the amount of alcohol non-residents can bring into the state.
- Does Ithaca have any special alcohol events? Yes, Ithaca hosts several annual events, including the Ithaca Beer Week and the Ithaca Festival, which feature local breweries and wineries.
- Can I order alcohol online for delivery in Ithaca? Yes, there are several online retailers that offer alcohol delivery in Ithaca.
- What are the busiest times for liquor stores in Ithaca? Weekends and evenings tend to be busiest.
- Are there any discounts or promotions I should look for? Many liquor stores offer discounts on bulk purchases, loyalty programs, and special promotions.
Conclusion
Ithaca, NY, offers an impressive array of liquor stores that cater to various tastes, budgets, and preferences. Whether you’re seeking a cozy neighborhood shop, a well-stocked retail chain, or a destination for rare and exclusive spirits, Ithaca has something to offer. By exploring the stores highlighted in this guide, you can embark on a delightful journey through Ithaca’s vibrant liquor scene and find the perfect beverages to complement your next social gathering, culinary experience, or solitary indulgence.